Enjoying Men’s Anal Sex: A Complete First-Timer’s Guide

Big picture

Plugs, Toy’s, Chastity Gear, Cock Rings and So Much More

It’s not “just for gay men.” Plenty of straight and bi men enjoy anal play with partners of any gender. Bodies don’t have sexual orientations—people do. The prostate (a pleasure center reachable through the rectum) is a common reason many men find anal play intensely enjoyable.
Consent, comfort, communication. Agree on boundaries, words to slow/stop, and check in often. Pleasure grows where pressure drops.
Safety is sexy. A little prep, lots of lubricant, and a slow pace turn “tense and painful” into “relaxed and pleasurable.”

Anatomy & sensation 101

Two sphincters: an outer ring you can control and an inner ring that relaxes with time, breath, and arousal. Rushing against them causes pain.
The prostate: 2–3 inches inside toward the front (belly) side. Gentle, rhythmic pressure—not jabbing—can feel uniquely good.

Health & safety basics

STI risk: Receptive anal sex has higher transmission risk for some STIs (including HIV). Use condoms, consider PrEP (if appropriate), and test regularly.
Lube is non-negotiable: Choose thick water-based or silicone-based lubricant. Reapply generously. Avoid oil with latex condoms.
Barriers & toys: If sharing toys between partners or switching from anal to oral/genital contact, use new condoms on toys and change them when switching or cleaning.
Hygiene: A warm shower and a gentle external wash are enough for most. If you prefer a rinse, use a small bulb with lukewarm water, minimal volume, and avoid over-douching (it can irritate).
Nails & hands: Trim/file nails, wash hands, and consider nitrile gloves with a bit of lube for comfort and cleanliness.
Pain ≠ goal: Mild stretching pressure or a “full” feeling is normal at first; sharp pain means stop, add lube, slow down, or try smaller.

Mindset & preparation

Relaxation first: Warm up with kissing, massage, shower together—anything that lowers tension. Deep belly breaths help relax the pelvic floor.
Start small: Begin with a lubricated fingertip or a beginner plug. Let the muscle “invite” the toy in—never force.
Positions that help beginners:
- On your side with top leg raised: easy to communicate and control depth.
- On your back with hips elevated (pillow under butt): great access to prostate, easy to slow/stop.
- On all fours: angle can be pleasurable; still go slowly.

Step-by-step for your first time (non-graphic)

Talk it through: What you’re curious about, what’s off-limits, stop words (“red”), slow words (“yellow”).
Gather supplies: Condoms, plenty of lube, towels, a small beginner toy, and a bottle of water nearby.
Arousal first: Don’t skip foreplay; tension drops and natural receptivity rises.
Warm-up: External circles around the opening, then a well-lubed fingertip; pause and breathe at each ring of muscle.
Gradual progression: If using toys, choose narrow, tapered, flared-base plugs. Insert on an exhale, hold still, then gently explore.
If and when you move to a penis: Keep the tip well-lubed, start with shallow, still insertion. The receiver controls pace and depth. Add more lube than you think you need.
Feedback loop: “A little slower,” “stay there,” “smaller,” “more lube,” are all useful. Adjust continuously.
Aftercare: Remove slowly on an exhale. Clean up, cuddle, hydrate. Check in about what felt good and what didn’t.

Lube guide (quick picks)

Water-based (thick/gel): Condom-safe, easy clean-up; reapply as needed.
Silicone-based: Very slick, long-lasting, also condom-safe; can degrade some silicone toys (check manufacturer).
Hybrid: Water + silicone blends; often a nice middle ground.

Toys & training sets

Beginner plugs: Small, tapered, with a flared base. Wear briefly at first (10–20 minutes), increase over time as comfortable.
Prostate massagers: Curved toys targeting the prostate; start gently and let the sensation build.
What to avoid: Anything without a flared base (risk of getting lost), rough seams, or oversized devices “to get it over with.” There’s nothing to “get over”—only to enjoy, gradually.

Common worries & fixes

“Will it be messy?” With light prep (shower, optional small rinse) and going slowly, accidents are uncommon. Keep wipes and a towel handy; it’s a body, not a museum.
“It hurts when I try.” Pain usually means too fast, too big, too dry, or too tense. Downgrade size, add more lube, breathe, and return to external play.
Hemorrhoids/fissures: If you have active irritation, wait until healed. Persistent bleeding, severe pain, or fever warrants medical care.
Condoms slipping/breaking: Use a snug fit, squeeze air from the tip, add lube on the outside (and a tiny bit inside the tip), and avoid oil with latex.

Etiquette & communication

Before: Share boundaries and curiosities; agree on stop/slow words.
During: Check-ins (“1–10, how’s that?”), keep responses short and honest.
After: Debrief: what to repeat, what to tweak, what to try next time.

Myths, busted

“Anal sex is only for gay men.” False. Orientation is about who you’re attracted to, not which nerves you stimulate.
“It should hurt the first time.” No. With prep and patience, discomfort can be minimal to none.
“Bigger is better.” Comfort and control beat size; pleasure comes from angle, rhythm, and relaxation.

Making it pleasurable (not just possible)

Angle for the prostate: Think “toward the belly” with gentle pressure or a subtle rocking motion.
Tempo & rhythm: Stillness at first helps muscles relax; slow, shallow motion often feels best to begin.
Combine sensations: External stroking, kissing, or toys on the perineum (between scrotum and anus) can heighten pleasure.

When to pause or stop

Sharp or escalating pain, dizziness, nausea, condom breakage, or bleeding more than a light smear. Stop, assess, and switch to non-penetrative play or call it for the day.

Cultural note

Attitudes toward anal sex vary widely across cultures and communities. In many places and relationships, it’s a mainstream, consensual part of adult intimacy—no more “taboo” than any other kind of mutually enjoyed play.

Quick checklist (first-timer edition)

☐ Talk boundaries & stop words
☐ Condoms + lots of lube
☐ Trim nails / optional gloves
☐ Start small (finger/toy), go slow
☐ Breathe, exhale on insertion
☐ Receiver controls pace/depth
☐ Aftercare, hydration, debrief

Final thoughts

Anal play is a skill and a collaboration. With curiosity, patience, and mutual respect, it can be tender, intense, playful—or all three. Go slow, stay communicative, and prioritize comfort. If you’d like, I can tailor a beginner starter kit list (condom types, lube options, toy sizes) or adapt this guide for solo play, couples, or specific body concerns.